Resource Logo

Hello, you are using an old browser that's unsafe and no longer supported. Please consider updating your browser to a newer version, or downloading a modern browser.

Receive Updates
Resource Arrow Back to all
Date: January 23, 2019
Category: Credit

In 3 Points: Navigating an Impending Fixed-income Liquidity Crisis

You could say liquidity is like good health – you don’t appreciate it until your doctor is your new best friend.

While market risk can be easily judged by price fluctuation – and we’ve had to do such explaining in recent months – liquidity risk isn’t always felt until you go to sell. Put simply, liquidity for bond investors is the ability to sell at a reasonable price within a reasonable time frame. If one investor can’t sell, there’s usually others. Crises occur quickly, with an avalanche of price drops triggering more selling … and then further price drops.

Before such a domino effect cascades through the fixed-income markets, you should understand how we got here, what a crisis might look like, and strategies to avoid potential loss in the “safe” portion of portfolios.

More risk now sits with investors

Before 2008, even the most esoteric bonds could be sold relatively easily. Big investment banks acted as principals responsible for lining up buyers and sellers. These “too-big-to-fail” institutions held massive inventories of bonds and loans, which helped keep prices in check. Now, post-crisis regulations have reduced banks’ ability to warehouse the risk that once promoted the orderly trading of credit markets.

That’s a big deal within a semi-liquid asset class. Bonds and loans aren’t exchange traded like stocks. Instead bonds and loans are traded over-the-counter in a brokered market. As a result, the liquidity risk has moved from the balance sheets of investment banks to portfolios of individual investors.

This new market’s stress tests

While past performance does not equal future results, there are several recent guides to help predict a reaction. Both the Taper Tantrum of 2013 and Flash Crash of 2014 caused a significant down draft on fixed-income markets. In 2013, Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke announced that the Fed would end quantitative easing, causing market hysteria. Then, in 2014, U.S. Treasuries experienced one of the largest intraday changes in yields, larger even than the decline prompted by Lehman Brothers filing for bankruptcy (September 15, 2008). Both illustrate that market shocks easily “flash” when liquidity is low. Investors can no longer rely on dealers to provide liquidity in volatile markets.

Is a liquidity crisis hiding in plain sight?

Let’s fast forward to last month, when investors pulled $2.2 billion from all loan mutual funds and ETFs in just a four-day window.1 Amidst fears of an economic slowdown, from mid-November to mid-December, withdrawals from the asset class reached almost $9 billion. Bloomberg noted that Lord, Abbett & Co. and Eaton Vance Management were among the fund managers selling holdings to meet redemption requests.

It doesn’t matter if the market was rational – and we’d argue that December’s job reports emphatically says it was the exact opposite. Panic is not liquidity’s friend. Take a look at the following three charts to illustrate the net asset value deterioration possible when a liquid fund is forced to sell illiquid underlying holdings at a loss into a panicked market. Asset sales may cause liquidity issues, which may further impact asset prices.

NAV deterioration vs. NAV noise

Interval funds offer a potential solution to avoid principal erosion in this environment. Many fixed-income interval funds mark their loans and bonds to the market, but thanks to their quarterly liquidity feature, they can typically hold on to these investments in this environment. Experienced fund managers can block out the noise and strategically buy at a discount instead of selling at one.

Go Deeper Into Today’s Potential Liquidity Crisis

1 Bloomberg. Major Investors in Leveraged Loans Are Unloading Big Chunks. 12/19/18.

Resource Securities LLC, Member FINRA/SIPC.

The above communication is intended to be educational in nature and provide additional resources for current and/or prospective clients. Resource derives most, if not all, of its revenue based on the sale of its various products. While subject to change, Resource has a non-traded REIT and two interval funds available to investors. This is neither an offer to sell nor a solicitation of an offer to buy a Resource product; an offering is made only by prospectus or other offering memorandum. This information must be preceded or accompanied by a prospectus in order to understand fully all of the implications and risks of the offering. Neither the Attorney General of the State of New York nor any other state regulators have passed on or endorsed the merits of a Resource product. Any representation to the contrary is a criminal offense.

Investing in real estate or credit products involves a high degree of risk and uncertainties which should be carefully considered when making an investment decision. If any of the risks were to occur, the value of your investment may decline, and you could lose some or all of your investment. Some of these risks related to available Resource products may include the following: no public market exists for the investment and liquidity by a specified date is not guaranteed; the purchase price of your investment may not reflect the underlying value of the security; limited operating history for the program; no investments identified to acquire with the equity raised; dependence on an external advisor to select investments and to conduct operations; payment of substantial fees to the advisor that increase the risk investors will not earn a profit on their investment; conflicts of interest; the use of leverage to acquire investments; restrictions on the ownership and transferability of an investment; distributions may be sourced from offering proceeds or borrowings. Refer to the applicable offering document for a complete set of risk factors. Offering materials and offering-specific risk factors for Resource products may be found at

Receive Updates

* These fields are required.

Emails will only be sent to financial advisors. If you are not a financial advisor, please visit our website often for the latest educational content.